Contact us
Please note that we cannot offer Legal aid
What is workplace bullying?
Legal Framework and Solutions
Burden of Proof and Legal Proceedings
Impact and Future Developments
PacisLexis Family Law
Bullying in the workplace lawyer
Workplace bullying is a significant issue that can lead to severe consequences for both employees and employers.
It damages employee well-being, reduces productivity, and can create a toxic work environment.
Different legal systems address workplace bullying in distinct ways, particularly when comparing the French civil law system with the common law system found in countries like the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada.
In France, workplace bullying, or “harcèlement moral,” is legally defined under Article L.1152-1 of the French Labour Code. It includes repeated actions that degrade the working conditions of an employee, affecting their dignity, physical or mental health, or professional future. These actions must be intentional and repetitive.
Workplace bullying remains a critical issue that requires strong legal responses to protect employees and maintain healthy work environments. The French legal system, with its specific definitions and proactive measures, provides a clear framework for addressing bullying. In contrast, common law systems offer varied but often reactive remedies. Both systems have their strengths and areas for improvement, and each can learn from the other. Understanding these legal differences is crucial for those affected by workplace bullying, as well as for employers aiming to comply with their legal obligations.
Bullying in the workplace lawyer
What is worplace bullying?
What is worplace bullying?
Workplace bullying refers to repeated, unreasonable, and hostile behavior directed at an employee or group of employees, creating a risk to their health and safety. It can include verbal abuse, intimidation, exclusion, or manipulation, often aimed at undermining or controlling the victim.
Key characteristics of workplace bullying include:
- Persistent criticism, insults, or humiliation
- Sabotaging someone’s work or reputation
- Withholding information needed to perform tasks
- Isolating or excluding an individual from activities
- Threatening job security or career progression
Bullying can occur between colleagues, supervisors, or even subordinates, and can cause significant emotional, mental, and physical harm to the victim.
How does the common law system define workplace bullying?
Yes!
Psychological and emotional abuse is a step before physical abuse.
This is why you must talk to health carers or professionals, close relatives or friends before it’s too late.
- Physical abuse: physical abuse involves causing injuries or traumas such as bruises, broken bones, burns, cuts and is not accidental.
- Sexual abuse: it’s when an individual is coerced or physically forced to engage against their will or touches another person sexually without their consent: rapes, sexual harassment, ….
- Economic abuse: economic abuse involves the control of money and finances and things that money can buy. Perpetrators of economic abuse can control how you acquire or spend money, exploit incomes including food, clothing, accommodation.
How do these definitions affect the legal outcomes for victims?
The precise definition in French law offers clear criteria for legal action, making it easier for victims to file claims. In contrast, the absence of a clear definition in common law systems often requires victims to categorize bullying under broader legal frameworks, which can complicate their cases.
How does the legal recognition of workplace bullying influence workplace culture?
In France, the legal recognition of bullying encourages companies to implement preventative measures and create a respectful work environment.
In common law jurisdictions, the less explicit recognition can lead to variations in how seriously different organizations address workplace bullying.
What are the limitations of the definitions provided in both legal systems?
While the French definition is precise, it may overlook subtle forms of bullying that do not meet the criteria of repetition or intentionality.
In common law systems, the broader categories can encompass various behaviours, but the lack of specificity may leave some bullying behaviours unaddressed.
Bullying in the workplace lawyer
Legal frameworks and remedies
What are the legal remedies available under French law?
In France, employees facing workplace bullying can seek various remedies, including filing complaints with labour inspectors, taking legal action in labour courts, and seeking compensation for damages.
Employers found guilty of failing to prevent bullying can face significant fines and, in severe cases, criminal charges.
How do common law systems address workplace bullying?
In common law countries, the remedies available depend on the jurisdiction. In the U.S., for example, employees might pursue claims under civil rights laws, the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA), or specific state laws.
In the UK, remedies might be sought under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997, anti-discrimination laws, or through employment tribunals.
What are the differences in employer obligations under each system?
French law imposes stringent requirements on employers to prevent workplace bullying, including mandatory risk assessments, training, and internal policies.
Common law systems tend to focus more on addressing incidents after they occur, with less emphasis on mandatory preventative measures.
How accessible are legal remedies for employees in each system?
In France, the labour courts provide a relatively accessible avenue for employees to pursue claims. In common law countries, the process can be more complex and costly, especially in jurisdictions where cases are handled by civil courts rather than specialised labour courts.
What are the potential consequences for employers found guilty of failing to prevent workplace bullying?
In France, employers can face significant financial penalties, civil liability, and even criminal charges.
In common law countries, consequences vary but may include damages awards, penalties, or corrective orders.
How do cultural differences impact the implementation of these legal frameworks?
In France, there is a strong emphasis on protecting workers’ rights, which is reflected in the proactive nature of its legal framework.
Common law systems, particularly in the U.S., often place more responsibility on the employee to prove their case, reflecting a more adversarial legal culture.
Bullying in the workplace lawyer
Burden of proof and legal proceedings
Who bears the burden of proof in workplace bullying cases in France?
In French law, once an employee provides evidence suggesting bullying, the burden shifts to the employer to prove that the behaviour in question was not bullying or was justified.
This shared burden of proof aims to protect employees who may struggle to gather evidence against their employers.
How does the burden of proof differ in common law systems?
In common law systems, the burden of proof typically rests heavily on the employee.
The victim must provide clear evidence that the bullying occurred and that it meets the legal criteria for any claims they are pursuing, such as discrimination or constructive dismissal.
What challenges do employees face when trying to meet the burden of proof?
Employees may struggle to obtain evidence, especially if the bullying is subtle, happens in private, or involves intimidation from superiors.
In common law systems, where the burden of proof is higher, this can be a significant barrier to justice.
How do the types of evidence required differ between the two systems?
In France, evidence can include witness statements, medical reports, and documentation of the alleged bullying.
Common law systems may require more comprehensive evidence, such as detailed records, corroborating testimonies, and, in some cases, expert witness analysis.
What procedural differences exist in the legal processes between the two systems?
French labour courts are specialised in handling workplace disputes, making them more accessible and streamlined for employees.
In common law countries, workplace bullying cases may need to go through civil courts or specialised employment tribunals, which can be more adversarial and time-consuming.
How do these procedural differences affect the likelihood of a successful outcome for employees?
The more accessible and specialised nature of French labour courts generally increases the chances of a successful outcome for employees.
In common law jurisdictions, the complexity and adversarial nature of proceedings can make success less certain, especially for those without legal representation.
Bullying in the workplace lawyer
Impact and future developments
What is the impact of the French approach on workplace culture?
The French legal system’s strong stance on workplace bullying fosters a culture of respect and proactive prevention within organizations.
However, it can also lead to challenges such as overly cautious work environments or false claims, which can strain employer-employee relationships.
How is the common law system evolving to address workplace bullying?
Common law countries are increasingly recognizing the need for more explicit laws and protections against workplace bullying.
For example, some U.S. states have introduced “Healthy Workplace” bills, and the UK has seen calls for clearer legislation.
These changes indicate a growing shift towards adopting some of the preventative measures seen in civil law systems like France.
What role do societal attitudes play in shaping the legal frameworks for workplace bullying?
In France, societal values emphasize worker protection, influencing the comprehensive nature of its laws.
In common law countries, particularly the U.S., there is a stronger focus on individual responsibility and litigation, which shapes a more reactive legal framework.
How can the French system improve to better address workplace bullying?
While the French system is robust, improvements could include better mechanisms to address false allegations and to ensure that subtle forms of bullying are recognized even if they don’t meet the current criteria for frequency or intent.
What lessons can common law systems learn from the French approach?
Common law systems could benefit from adopting more proactive measures, such as mandatory workplace policies, regular training on harassment, and a clearer definition of workplace bullying.
These measures could help reduce incidents of bullying before they escalate into legal disputes.
What are the implications of future legal developments on workplace bullying prevention?
As both legal systems evolve, there could be greater convergence, with common law systems adopting more preventive approaches and civil law systems, like France’s, incorporating more flexibility in addressing individual cases.
This evolution could lead to more comprehensive and effective protection for employees worldwide.
To help you
and to care
PacisLexis Family Law
Are you experiencing workplace bullying?
If you are experiencing workplace bullying, don’t hesitate to seek help. Contact our office today to book an appointment with a specialized workplace bullying lawyer who can provide you with the guidance and support you need.
Protect your rights and well-being—schedule a consultation now.
PacisLexis Family Law
OUR CLIENT REVIEWS
PacisLexis Family Law
Our articles about abuse and harassment
Domestic abuse
In France, domestic abuse is referred to as “violences conjugales” or “violences au sein du couple.” It encompasses a range of behaviours that occur within a domestic or marital relationship and can include physical violence, psychological abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse, and economic control.
The definition and legal consequences of domestic abuse in France are primarily governed by the French Civil Law and the French criminal Law (‘’Code Pénal). The specific legal provisions related to domestic abuse can be complex and may vary depending on the circumstances and the severity of the abuse.
Protection orders
In France, a protection order or restraining order is known as “ordonnance de protection.” It is a legal measure made to protect victims of domestic abuse or harassment. This order can be issued by a judge and may include a range of provisions to ensure the safety and well-being of the person who has been subjected to abuse or threats. The specific provisions of a protection order can vary based on the individual circumstances.
Child abduction
What is child abduction?
“L’enlevement parental” or child abduction in English is when a person takes a minor out of France without the consent of those with parental responsibility.
It can be a child’s parent.
“l’enlevement parental” is not a legal word, only abduction is and is a criminal offence in France.
When child abduction is suspected, you must react quickly. Child abduction is a sensitive and complex matter that can cause stress and anxiety for everyone involved.
It’s important to note that in France, parental responsibility is shared. You do not need the other parent’s agreement to take a child abroad.